Matthew 1:18-25
Now the birth of Jesus the Messiah took place in this way. When his mother Mary had been engaged to Joseph, but before they lived together, she was found to be pregnant from the Holy Spirit. Her husband Joseph, being a righteous man and unwilling to expose her to public disgrace, planned to divorce her quietly. But just when he had resolved to do this, an angel of the Lord appeared to him in a dream and said, “Joseph, son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife, for the child conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit. She will bear a son, and you are to name him Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins.” All this took place to fulfill what had been spoken by the Lord through the prophet:
“Look, the virgin shall become pregnant and give birth to a son, and they shall name him Emmanuel,” which means, “God is with us.”
When Joseph awoke from sleep, he did as the angel of the Lord commanded him; he took her as his wife but had no marital relations with her until she had given birth to a son, and he named him Jesus.
After the initial flurry of fighting at the beginning of World War I, both the Germans and the Allies dug into trenches that stretched 440 miles across the Western Front from the boarder with Switzerland to the North Sea. In places, the trenches were just yards apart. Then… on Christmas Eve… something remarkable happened. A soldier on the German side put a make shift Christmas tree up on top of his trench and lit it up with candles. Then he started singing Silent Night. The English and the French on the other side didn’t know the German words but they knew the tune and they too began to sing. Then, slowly... here and there... someone would stick their head up out of the trench to see if the other side would shoot. No one did.
Make shift signs poked out of the German trenches. “WE NO FIGHT. YOU NO FIGHT.” The English made make shift banners too that said MERRY CHRISTMAS and put them up and waited for a response. Eventually men climbed out of their trenches and headed across no-man’s-land. The first thing they did was to retrieve the wounded and then buried their dead together. They exchanged food, tobacco, and souvenirs with one another, sang more carols with more familiar tunes, and played soccer.
It has since become known as the Christmas Truce. It was a truce that didn’t come negotiated by diplomats or ordered from above. It literally came out of the trenches. It was VERY unofficial. In fact, the leadership... the brass... didn’t like it at all... but it happened none the less. It started with one person... just one tired, lonely, cold, and hungry person who decided to put up a make shift Christmas tree and sing Silent Night instead of choosing to continue the fight. The choice that one person made... to set up a tree and sing rather than fight... spread up and down the line on both sides.
All the stories you read about this event use words like “unbelievable,” “impossible,” “unprecedented” or “up side down” to describe the Christmas Truce. But what if, for just that short amount of time, there between the trenches of war... right there immersed in the power of Emmanuel... the power of “God with us”... what if the world WASN’T up side down at all, but instead... what if in THAT brief time where hatred and anger and violence were set aside... what if in THAT moment, the world was actually… RIGHT SIDE UP?
Why is it, that we continue to believe that hatred and grudges, divisions and fear are “normal” while the choice to set aside suffering, loneliness, and separation and share a meal and some songs together is “unbelievable” and “up side down”? This story from over a hundred years ago reminds us, that with the power of Emmanuel, God with us… with the power of faith over fear… those ways of violence, resentment, retribution, and suffering that so many in the world call “normal” are actually NOT AT ALL NORMAL! Those ways of violence, resentment, retribution, and suffering DO NOT HAVE TO BE OUR WAY ANY MORE!
Think about it. If a soldier who had been actively shot, shelled, gassed, and bombed... if a soldier who had been living in the mud and muck of a barbed wire lined trench with not enough to eat or drink... if a soldier who had been through all of that could decide, strengthened by the power of Emmanuel, God with us… to set up a little candle lit tree and sing Silent Night instead of continuing to seek revenge for all he had endured… isn’t there a chance that with the power of Emmanuel… with the power of God with us… with the power of God’s love coming into the world… isn’t it possible that we could do it too?
You and I don’t have a world war to set aside, but our world continues to insist that we must act out of our fear fueled anger, hatred, and resentment with violence. We saw it at Brown University. We saw it on the beach in Australia. We saw it in the malevolent post the president made in the wake of Rob and Michelle Reiner’s murder. We see it in our country as immigrants and refugees are called garbage and are pulled off the street by our country’s gestapo for the crime of being brown. And… if we are honest… we see it in ourselves too… as we choose suffering rather than choosing to embrace radical acceptance and forgiveness that, while it can not undo the past, it can and will free us for the future.
We’ve been led and conditioned to believe that holding onto resentments, hurts, and division is “normal”... that getting even is simply how the world works... that any other way would turn the world UPSIDE DOWN. But this Gospel lesson demands that we hear... that is simply NOT TRUE! Hate, fear, violence, revenge and grudges AREN’T “normal” and they DON'T bring us life. This Gospel story reminds us that living our lives in faith rather than fear… practicing lives of love, peace, generosity, compassion and sharing with one another is REALLY how God wants us to live so that we might all live abundantly!
Over a hundred years ago one soldier... just one… literally stopped a whole World War with just a make shift Christmas tree and a song. The power of Emmanuel, it turned out, had the power to transform the most violent place in the WHOLE WORLD into a place of peace. One soldier, deciding to do something different. Is there any reason you and I could not choose, right here... right now, to do the same?
May the power of Emmanuel, God with us, remind us that we do NOT have to live the way kings and kaisers, presidents and pundits proclaim is “normal.” May the power of Emmanuel, God with us, remind us that we can choose a life of faith rather than a life of fear. And may the power of Emmanuel, God with us, remind us that we can choose (regardless of the horrors happening around us) to live the Way of Emmanuel… the way of “God with us”… the way of the Prince of Peace. Amen.


